If you are interested in working on a special issue for the journal, a three-stage
process is in place:
1. Proposal submission: To propose a special issue, guest editors should submit to the following information in raw text:
If the proposed special issue is not the result of a conference/workshop, the Call for Papers that the guest editors plan to issue should be included as part of the proposal submission.
The journal Editors-In-Chief will communicate to the guest editors whether the proposal shows promise for a special issue, and provide specific guidelines, if appropriate.
2. Preliminary paper submission: To ensure that the special
issue papers are within the scope and style of the journal, the journal editors
preview the individual preliminary papers and communicate any suggestions or
concerns to the guest editors before major effort has been invested in revising
or refereeing them.
If the papers selected for the special issue have been published in short form in a conference or workshop, guest editors should send them in their previously published form, as soon as they become available. If the papers have not been published elsewhere, guest editors should send their initial versions before sending them out for review. The preliminary paper submission should contain the following in a single zip file (to facilitate review):
Validation. Papers published in CI must contain a substantial validation of their claims, either as a theoretical development (proofs), or as a thorough experimental evaluation and detailed comparison with existing methods, demonstrating the significance of the proposed methods. Conceptual frameworks that lack such validation are not acceptable. Preliminary papers submitted must contain a sufficient validation component to proceed to the next stage.
3. Full paper package submission. The papers that have been identified as potentially suitable for publication by the journal editors in stage 2 above will be extended by the authors (if previously published) and sent to referees at arm's length from the authors by the guest editors. The refereeing process (reviewer assignment and review submission) will be carried out through the journal's Manuscript Central Submission Site
The authors will submit their papers to Manuscript Central following the Submission
Instructions, noting on the first (title) page of the paper,
and the cover letter (step 5 of the manuscript submission process, in the free text box, not in an attached file):
(a) the full names and email addresses of the guest editors.
(b) the full title of the special issue.
(c) full name, abbreviation and date (YYYY-MM-DD) of the conference or workshop on which the special issue is based (if applicable).
The proposed special issue editor(s) will serve as the action editor(s) for each paper for which he/she is not an author.
4. Guest editor set up on Manuscript Central
Guest editors should create their own Manuscript Central accounts by:
- visiting http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/coin and selecting "Create Account" in the upper right corner of the page.
- sending email to , so that their account is upgraded to Action Editor status.
In case of more than one guest editor, manuscripts will be assigned to the guest editor specified in step 2, by the journal Editor-in-Chief (EIC) responsible for the special issue. To send email to the EIC, the guest editor should click on the EIC's name in the Manuscript Central display of the manuscript. This way the manuscript information is automatically included in the email, and the message is archived.
5. Content guidelines
For papers published elsewhere, it is required that the special issue versions be substantially different from their already published forms. New proofs, theories or experimental results would qualify, while extending referenced literature, or slightly changing the writing would not. As a guideline, there should be at least 30% new research results in the journal version compared to a prior conference or workshop version. Special issues must be under 200 pages, with papers at least 5,000 words long. Using the Wiley-Blackwell Author Guidelines, a typical 5,000 word submission is between 14-22 pages. To conform with this requirement, a maximum of 10 papers can be submitted for review for a special issue.
6. Responsibilities of the guest editor
The editors-in-chief have the right to reject any paper for which the above guidelines have not been followed, at any point during the process.
For any questions, please contact: